Were you aware that medieval asylums were not sanctuaries, but rather sites of profound suffering? Envision institutions where ignorance fueled the torture of vulnerable individuals under the guise of rudimentary science. In this episode, we will expose this dark period in its entirety, revealing how these brutal practices contributed to the enduring stigma surrounding mental illness. We will delve into historical accounts to confront a harsh reality: our ancestors were not always more compassionate, but often more ignorant, and this ignorance persists in contemporary society.

Before we embark on this difficult exploration of historical truth, we invite you to share your perspectives on these abhorrent practices. To ensure you do not miss any future episodes of Unveiling History, please subscribe to our documentary channel.

The Misunderstood Mind

During the Middle Ages, the human mind was considered an even greater mystery than the cosmos itself. While physical ailments were attributed to humoral imbalances, mental illnesses were often interpreted as gateways to other realms, potentially influenced by unseen forces. The belief that jinn and demons could manipulate the human mind, and that black magic was a primary cause of mental dysfunction, was widespread and deeply ingrained in societal beliefs. Individuals exhibiting symptoms of mental illness, ranging from hallucinations to seizures, were often perceived as possessed or cursed, leading to fear and social ostracism rather than compassion and support.

Exorcism and the Malleus Maleficarum

Exorcism rituals became a common form of intervention. Intense prayers, incantations, and even physical torture were employed in an attempt to expel perceived demonic entities from the afflicted individual. The publication of the Malleus Maleficarum (Hammer of Witches) in 1487 further exacerbated intolerance, asserting that women were particularly susceptible to witchcraft and, consequently, mental illness, leading to an increase in persecution and false accusations. Amidst this pervasive darkness, some voices advocated for compassion and rationality, such as Hildegard of Bingen, who proposed that mental illnesses might have natural causes. However, these voices were often overshadowed by superstition and widespread ignorance.

Trepanation: Drilling into the Mind

Trepanation, a term that resonates with unsettling historical significance, evokes images of early, often misguided attempts to understand the human mind. This brutal surgical procedure, involving the drilling of a hole in the skull, was employed during the Middle Ages and even millennia prior as a purported remedy for various mental illnesses. Imagine a human skull undergoing this primitive operation, potentially using crude stone or metal instruments, in a desperate attempt to release malevolent spirits believed to be tormenting the patient. Archaeological evidence reveals skulls with trepanation holes dating back to the Neolithic era, indicating the long-standing prevalence of this practice. Trepanation was believed to alleviate pressure within the skull or to expel the malevolent entities thought to cause seizures and mental disorders.

Disturbingly, archaeological findings suggest that some individuals survived trepanation, exhibiting signs of bone healing around the drilled holes. However, whether this survival indicates the efficacy of trepanation as a treatment or simply reflects the human body’s resilience under extreme conditions remains a matter of debate. During the Middle Ages, this gruesome practice persisted despite a lack of scientific understanding of mental illness. While Hippocrates described trepanation in his writings, he primarily associated it with head injuries and epilepsy, not necessarily mental ailments. The continued use of this brutal practice serves as a stark reminder of the despair and ignorance that characterized the treatment of individuals with mental disorders during that era. However, the horrific practices did not stop there.

Bloodletting and Purging: Attempts at Humoral Balance

Perhaps one of the most disturbing beliefs was that madness stemmed from an excess of blood or toxic humors disrupting the body’s equilibrium. This belief led to the implementation of two brutal practices: bloodletting and purging. Envision patients restrained while their arms or legs were cut open, allowing blood to flow freely in the hope of expelling the madness. In prominent European hospitals, such as Bedlam in London, bloodletting was a routine and often merciless procedure. Furthermore, patients were subjected to induced vomiting or severe diarrhea through the administration of potent laxatives, such as black hellebore, or harsh herbal remedies. The prevailing rationale was that purging would restore the body’s balance by eliminating the purported toxic substances causing madness. Even in the seventeenth century, physician Thomas Willis defended bloodletting as a necessary measure to purify the contaminated blood of mental patients. The tragic irony is that these procedures were often performed with unsterilized instruments, leading to serious infections and complications, compounding the suffering of those already afflicted with mental illness. These harmful interventions persisted until the nineteenth century, despite the absence of scientific evidence supporting their efficacy.

Exorcism and Religious Intervention

During this era of pervasive ignorance, churches and monasteries became sites of futile attempts to combat perceived supernatural forces. Mental illnesses were not viewed as conditions requiring medical treatment but as evidence of demonic possession. Instead of seeking genuine healing, individuals were subjected to terrifying exorcism rituals. Imagine a patient shackled and confined to a dark, suffocating cell while priests recited prayers in Latin. Holy water was forcefully splashed on the patient’s face, and crosses were brandished as if they were sacred weapons. These rituals were believed to compel the devil to depart from the patient’s body, but in reality, they only exacerbated the individual’s suffering. Saint Benedict, considered a protector against evil, was frequently invoked during these rituals. However, whether these prayers provided solace or intensified the torment remains questionable. In some instances, physical torture was incorporated into the ritual, with beatings and food deprivation employed to weaken the perceived demonic presence, disregarding the patient’s actual pain. Patients were often isolated in monasteries or churches, further compounding their feelings of loneliness and despair. While these rituals were intended to liberate them from evil, they often resulted in their perpetual confinement within a system of fear and ignorance.

Asylums: From Havens to Prisons

Asylums, intended as havens for patients, often devolved into merciless prisons. At St. Mary Bethlehem Hospital, or the infamous Bedlam in London, patients were treated as prisoners, chained to walls and floors, and deprived of basic human rights. Imagine the oppressive darkness, the constant screams, and the pervasive atmosphere of despair. By the fifteenth century, this torment became a public spectacle, with visitors paying a small fee to observe the suffering of the patients. Human suffering was reduced to cheap entertainment, a brutal exploitation of their vulnerability. In France, treatment methods were equally brutal, including continuous spinning on a rotating chair until the patient fainted, a practice falsely believed to calm them. This constituted torture disguised as pseudo-science. At York Hospital in England, records document deaths resulting from neglect and starvation, highlighting a disregard for human life. Harsh enemas, excessive bloodletting, and forced vomiting were employed in attempts to cleanse the body of “black vapors.” Straitjackets were used to restrict movement for extended periods, leading to muscle atrophy and circulatory problems. Sudden cold baths were administered as a physical and emotional shock, further increasing the patient’s distress.

The Enduring Stigma

During this dark age, mental illness was an enduring stigma, considered incurable. It was not viewed as a condition warranting treatment but as a curse, divine punishment, or demonic possession that inspired fear. Imagine the horror experienced by families as they witnessed a loved one descend into a world of delirium and delusions. The fear of shame often outweighed the desire to provide help. Families concealed afflicted individuals in basements or attics, away from public scrutiny. This isolation exacerbated the illness, transforming homes into prisons. Outside, rumors spread, fueled by superstition and misinformation. Individuals with mental illness were often labeled as cursed, possessed, or as having angered the gods. However, not all interactions were negative. In some communities, individuals with mental illness were viewed with a mixture of awe and fear, perceived as possessing supernatural abilities or the capacity to communicate with spirits. This fear and suspicion led to avoidance or exploitation for divination and predictions. In the absence of laws protecting their rights, individuals with mental illness were vulnerable to abuse and exploitation.

The Lingering Shadows of the Past

The darkness of the Middle Ages did not entirely dissipate with the advent of science. Deeply ingrained beliefs that mental illness was a curse or demonic possession left lasting scars on societal perceptions. Even centuries after the publication of the Malleus Maleficarum, the echoes of this stigma persist. Many individuals suffer in silence, afraid to reveal their struggles for fear of judgment. Opportunities are missed, and dreams are shattered due to the negative stereotypes associated with mental illness. Bedlam, a symbol of suffering, continues to be referenced, even as its practices have evolved. However, whether societal attitudes have truly changed and whether we have overcome the brutal perspectives of the Middle Ages remains a question. A recent study indicates that nearly half of those with mental health problems

Watch the Documentary